|
2nd Season Stargate Atlantis - Michael - 5 star poll - SPOILERS AHOY !
Fri, 24 Feb 2006 20:21:48 -0800
rec.arts.tv
previous
George Avalos...
|
"Michael"
2-24-06 SGA
Rob Jensen...
|
5 stars (Moore)
0-1 stars (Jackson)
2.0 (Carrington, Grease 2)
-- Rob
|
5 stars (Jordan)
pv+usenet...
|
2.5. Silly, and the big secret was spoiled by the episode description, so I
have no idea whether I would have been fooled or not. I'm thinking not,
everybody was doing the shifty-eyes thing. *
|
0-1 stars (Moore)
ANIM8Rfsk...
|
1
They're back to "They all need to die"
ANIM8Rfsk...
|
Yep. I was *so* hoping she wouldn't backslide. Alas. :(
|
Atlas Bugged...
|
I am always one for heavy disbelief suspension, but you are right.
There have been at least four SGA's, where even though I love the show, you
are forced to conclude the characters acted too dumb to survive very long in
their circumstance. Obviously, a writing problem.
For example, everything involving Michael, if you were dumb enough to even
create him in the first place, should obviously have been done at the beta
site, with no mention of Atlantis.
The show needs to stop varying between "credible modern Trek replacement"
and "Darwin award applicants," even though the latter is the minority of the
time.
|
|
erilar...
|
It wasn't totally predictable! Wow! I'd almost give it a 4 . . .well 3.9
|
Dr.X...
|
1.
It was a stinker. I don't usually see sga that way, but this one... whew! I
had to spray the TV with deodorizer and hang a little paper evergreen car
freshener on my VCR.
whodunit...
|
whodunit...
|
4.5
I was surprised at the twist.
ANIM8Rfsk...
|
What twist?
That's a serious question. There wasn't a moment I didn't see coming. What
twist caught you by surprise?
whodunit...
|
That he was actually the bad guy, when in reality Weir et al were the
bad guys, experimenting on 'Michael'--without seeming regard for all
possible consequences (like exposing the fact that Atlantis had NOT been
destroyed)--these guys really need to think ahead sometimes.
|
|
Wish they'd gotten Trineer as a regular to the show, though.
He was one of my favorites on Enterprise.
|
|
|
