3rd Season Stargate Atlantis -

"Sateda"
8-4-06 SGA

5 stars (Wipmolen)

0-1 stars (Merwan)

Brandy Alexandre...

10!

Yay Ronin! I think they're grooming him for big screen action the way
they shot this ep with his battles, but I really like the character a
lot, and I super enjoyed getting the back story. Superior ep.

Anim8rFSK...

Oh, yeah, I forgot to score.

Brandy Alexandre...

You're just trying to negate mine. Quit stalking me! ;)

Anim8rFSK...

So many jokes. Silk Stalkings, Kapture (as in mitzi), yadda yadda yadda.

I can see why some people wouldn't like it, but it so totally fit
Ronin, if not the feel of the series. It still had the trademark SGA
humor in it when others were involved. I liked the exchange between
Sheprad and Tayla about his, um, I don't know...

Anim8rFSK...

I wonder if this one is breaking on gender grounds. The guys seem to
hate it, and the chicks (you, Mary Loomer Oliver (aka Erilar), chapman)

Brandy Alexandre...

No, because I should hate it because I didn't get to see enough of
my glib, elfin-eared Shepard.

dig it.

jayembee...

Hahahahahahahahaha...

My wife hated it; I thought it was "OK, but not one of the better ones".
The wife figures that it's a guy type of episode.

erilar...

I don't know about big screen, but I did enjoy this episode 8-) After
last week's fiasco I was braced for disappointment, but this was a
winner. Stingy as I am, I'll still give it a 4

Fred Ellis...

I give this episode 5 Stars. I found it to be a rip roarin' yarn. It
was nice to learn more about Ronin's past life.

cloud dreamer...

Ditto for me. Proof that one lacklustre episode doesn't make a trend.

The Duct Tape Avenger...

Seeing Ronan's back story is great, but ultimately the episode was an
excuse to make Stargate: Matrix.

Fred Ellis

stocksami...

4.0

I gave it extra credit for the back story on Ronin. The main story
wasn't anything special, but it did keep my attention, unlike last week.

Ken from Chicago...

4

Way better than last week and pretty good on its own.