Royal Genes


Safe For Kids





Anthology 3 feelings



16 Dec 2006 11:33:16 -0800 rec.music.beatles
previous


Richard Fangnail...
Did Ringo ask G Martin to write that instrumental intro to Don't Pass
Me By? It seems completely out of place with everything.

Jales...
It sounds more like a piece left out of the YS album.


I like the softer Obladi. The regular version sounds like Paul drank
too much coffee.

Junk and Teddy Boy are only passable songs although Junk has some good
parts.

Jales...
They should have removed the feedbacks.


I like this All Things Must Pass but that's because I like the song in
general.

Jales...
Like it. Maybe a little imprecise, rhythm-wise. (but of course it's a
demo!)


Helter Skelter has a haunting blues sound but it goes on way too long.

Jales...
But shorter than the much expected 27' version!!


Why two Glass Onion versions?

Jales...
Agreed 100%


When Paul wrote Come and Get It, why did he have some humming in place
of the words? He often did that in the writing process but would fill
it in later.

Jales...
Very good performance!

My additions:

Very good version of Cry Baby Cry, and finally Not Guilty and What's
The New Mary Jane are now official versions!

Jeff...
The second 2 you mentioned are garbage. 101 takes of "not guility" and
this version is the best that they could come up with? No wonder it
didn't make the white album.

Jales...
But IMHO Not Guilty is far better than Rev 9, Wild Honey Pie, Obladi
Oblada, Bungalow Bill, just to name a few songs from the same era


Jeff...
Obladi was a guitar demo..that's all..if you like them..you do.
next