Royal Genes


Safe For Kids





Re: SP Correction: Sir William Douglas and his Lindsay wife [II of II]



Thu, 18 May 2006 10:30:25 +0000 (UTC) soc.genealogy.medieval
previous


Therav3...
Dear Will,

The Erskine relationship is shown below, with certain
details missing (re: which, see my post to SGM, Sir James de Lindsay and Egidia Stewart> dated 11 June 2003).

Alexander Stewart = Joanna ____
__________________________I_______________
I I
James (the) Stewart NN Stewart
I I
I I
Walter = Marjory Sir Alexander = NN
Stewart I Bruce de Lindsay I
I I
I I
Robert II Sir Robert = Beatrix
K of Scots de Erskine I de Lindsay
I I
I I
ROBERT III SIR THOMAS de ERSKINE

Tim Powys-Lybbe...
SP, Vol 3, p. 9 says of Sir Alexander de Lindsay "There is reason to
believe that this wife was a sister of James, Steward of Scotland" for
which they give a reference of "See dispensation of 1346 below" and
which I can't locate!

Any views on SP's belief?


By the same relationship Sir James de Lindsay and his wife
Egidia Stewart were 2nd cousins 1x removed, Robert III and Sir
Thomas de Erskine were 3rd cousins.

The one relationship I can divine at present between Sir
Patrick de Graham and Robert III is based on my theory that
Helen of Strathearn, Patrick's mother, was dau. of Earl Malise
by his 2nd wife, Joanna de Menteith (see SGM threads, Addition: Helen of Strathearn, wife of Sir David Graham> dated
11 Nov 2005, and Menteith (revisited)> dated 2 Jan 2006).

Walter Stewart = B___ [Beatrice, or Bethoc ?]
_______________________I____________
I I
Alexander = Joanna ____ Walter = Mary of
Stewart I E of Menteith I Menteith
___I I
I I
James (the) Stewart Sir John de Menteith
I of Ruskie
I I_______
I I
Walter = Marjory Malise = 2) Joanna
Stewart I Bruce E of Strathearn I de Menteith
I I
I I
Robert II 2) Sir David = Helen of
K of Scots de Graham I Strathearn
I I
I I
ROBERT III SIR PATRICK de GRAHAM

By the foregoing, they would have been 4th cousins.
next