Royal Genes


Safe For Kids





Wood fires source of air pollution



18 Nov 2006 08:32:06 -0800 soc.retirement
previous


California Poppy...
Posted on Sat, Nov. 18, 2006

Officials try to snuff out wood fires
BAY AREA: Stricter particle limits prompt plea to residents to find
cleaner ways to warm up

Yez...
This discussion goes around a couple of times a year and as a person
who lives in the armpit of a medium sized city (El Cajon) I am very
much in favor of tightening regulations on emissions from folks
chimneys and barbecues. Just on this block there are probably 15 or
20 older wood burning fireplaces (most in apts), some folks burn
their hideously stinking trash in them, in the summer these same
people stoke up their barbecue grills by pouring a gallon of lighter
on them, the eye burning stench is awful, I have to close my windows
and turn on the air cleaners. We live so close together now in most
cities people need to give a bit more thought to their neighbors.

Yez...
Thoughtless people burning stinking lung irritants in the city *is*
a problem that affects everyone.

California Poppy...
I tried to post before and was told by web-search that I couldn't, so my
apologies if this appears twice.

Wood burning on a quiet, cool night causes terrible air pollution in
the SF East Bay. It bothers me more than any other kind of air
pollution. Mostly, new fireplaces and stoves are required to have
filters, but many of the old ones don't. It is quite serious for those
who have breathing problems.

jimstevens...
I don't know the West Coast well. From the few trips there, I was
under impression there was almost always some reasonably brisk breeze
that would deal with a BBQ grill or fireplace. I don't have the same
experience at all. Probably 15% or so of our neighbors use fireplaces
regularly and I have never, never had a problem. We do have some
space between homes and all I may get is a little whiff once in a
while. The smoke begins at second story level as it exits chimney and
goes from there.

Never heard of such problem. Interesting.

By Denis Cuff
CONTRA COSTA TIMES

Bay Area residents, who drove less in the summer to "Spare the Air,"
will be asked for the first time this winter to give up wood fires in
stoves and fireplaces to limit smoke on dirty air nights.

Stricter new health standards to protect the public from soot have
changed the threshold for when pollution regulators will ask for
voluntary cooperation in not burning wood fires on dirty nights. The
winter pollution season begins Monday and extends through Feb. 16.

"Our message is not to burn wood. It's one of the easiest choices
people can make to have a healthy community," said Karen Schkolnick,
spokeswoman for the nine-county Bay Area Air Quality Management
District.

The Bay Area's regional air pollution district has rarely issued the
winter no-burn advisories in the past. None were called last year.

But regulators say they expect to go to the media this winter to get
out the several advisories to protect people from ultra-fine particle
pollution linked to asthma, bronchitis, and other lung and heart
ailments.

The air isn't dirtier, but pollution levels acceptable in the past are
now considered harmful, officials say.

Some may consider the change a crimp in their winter traditions, but a
district study shows more area residents are opting not to burn wood in
old-fashioned open-hearth fireplaces.

"It's a cultural thing that many people have warm feelings about wood
fires," Schkolnick said, "but there is increasing scientific evidence
that the smoke can be harmful."

In its Spare the Air Tonight winter advisories, the air district also
will ask people to drive less because auto and truck exhaust is a major
source of particle pollution.

No free public transit rides will be offered in winter, however, as was
done on six dirty-air days last summer to fight smog, a hot-weather
problem.

The closer watch over winter pollution stems from the federal
Environmental Protection Agency's decision Sept. 21 to nearly halve its
allowable limit for concentrations of tiny particles 1/30th as thick as
a human hair.

The limit dropped from 65 to 35 micrograms per cubic meter.

Many studies suggested the tiny particles are more dangerous than
previously believed, especially to young children and the elderly, air
district officials say.

San Jose and Concord air monitoring stations historically have among
the highest particulate readings in the Bay Area, but they are not the
only places where past particle readings have topped the new limit.

Car and truck exhaust accounts for many of the fine particles in Bay
Area air on a day-to-day basis, but a surge in wood fires on cold
nights can push the air quality readings over the limit into the
unhealthy range, Schkolnick said.

Cold air can trap pollution close to ground so one fire in one
old-fashioned fireplace can smoke up a neighborhood.

The air district says the cleanest way to enjoy fires on cold nights is
in popular modern fireplaces that use natural gas to heat ceramic logs.

Some people will continue to burn wood, officials say.

For those who do, the air district recommends EPA-approved stoves, fire
boxes and fireplace inserts. These devices emit a fraction of the
pollution spewed out by old wood stoves and traditional open-hearth
fireplaces.

The newer wood-burning technology has secondary combustion chambers or
catalytic converters to destroy most pollution before venting exhaust
into the atmosphere.

The Bay Area air district has no current plans to ban wood fires on
dirty-air nights, as is done in the San Joaquin Valley.

However, if the district persistently fails to meet the stricter new
health standard, some mandatory limits on wood burning might be
considered, officials said.

Contact reporter Denis Cuff at 925-943-8267 or dcuff@cctimes.com.

karl...
What about stoves, wood heaters, etc with catalytic converters? They have
been offering them for YEARS and
they do cut down on emissions, cut creosete deposits in flues, and should
increase efficiency. Think about what's in 'smoke' unburned carbon laid
down on your chimneys walls or spewed out into the air is really high grade
fuel.

Cutting emissions & Using fuel more efficiently saves everyone alot of
trouble. Maybe you like chopping wood?
next